Separation & safety
The rules that keep aircraft apart, how conflicts are predicted, and what happens when it goes wrong. Plus terrain, restricted areas and TCAS.
The basic rule
Two aircraft in the air must be at least 3 nm apart sideways or 1,000 ft apart vertically. Either one is enough. Two aircraft 1 nm apart are fine if one is at 5,000 ft and the other at 6,000 ft; two at the same level are fine if they're 3 nm apart.
Exceptions
| Situation | Minimum |
|---|---|
| Both cleared for the same ILS (even if one is still turning on) 1.11 | 2.5 nm |
| Both established on the same ILS inside 10 nm of the runway 1.11 | 2 nm |
| A VFR light aircraft and anyone else | 1.5 nm or 500 ft |
| Two VFR light aircraft | No separation needed |
| Independent parallel approaches (established on parallel runways) | No separation needed between the two approaches |
| Close to the field (within 6 nm) with either aircraft below 1,500 ft | Tower's problem, not yours |
| A go-around flying the published missed approach off a parallel runway | Not counted against the other approach |
Conflict alerts
The game looks ahead 15, 30, 45 and 60 seconds on each pair's current heading, speed and climb. If they'd be too close at any of those moments, both go amber (CONFLICT) and you hear a warning tone. Act then: change one's level by 1,000 ft or turn one away.
From 1.11, aircraft on the same approach only get look-ahead warnings once both are established, and only over 30 seconds. A jet still turning onto the centreline isn't really flying a straight line, so straight-line predictions only produced false alarms.
Loss of separation
When two aircraft are actually too close, both go red (SEP LOST) and you hear an alert.
| Event | Standard | Hardcore |
|---|---|---|
| Loss of separation (each time a pair loses it) | −200 | −400 |
| Airprox: closer than 1 nm and 500 ft (on top of the loss) | −300 | −600 |
| Mid-air collision: closer than 0.2 nm and 250 ft | −1,000 each, and the shift ends | |
A pair is only charged once until they've separated again. In Relaxed mode a collision costs the points but doesn't end the shift.
TCAS
If two aircraft are about to pass within about 0.7 nm and 650 ft of each other, their collision-avoidance systems take over: one climbs and one descends about 1,500 ft (a resolution advisory, TCAS RA). While that's happening they won't take altitude instructions (“unable, TCAS resolution advisory”). After about 20 seconds they call “clear of conflict, returning to…” and go back to their assigned level. A TCAS event still counts against you.
Terrain
High ground shows its minimum safe altitude, for example MSA 35 = 3,500 ft. More than 5 nm from the field (and not established on an approach, or a departure climbing out):
- Below the MSA, you get a low altitude alert (
LOW ALT). Climb it. - Still below after 20 seconds: −100.
- Well below: the pilot gets a GPWS “terrain, pull up!”, climbs to safety on their own and ignores lower levels until clear (
PULL UP, −150).
Restricted areas
Hatched red circles such as R101 SFC–50 are restricted from the surface up to the number in hundreds of feet (here 5,000 ft). Aircraft above the top are fine. As an aircraft heads for one, its strip shows a warning tag (→R101). An aircraft that enters one below its top costs 120.
Storms
Flying into the core of a storm cell costs 60, and on final it causes a windshear go-around. See Weather & wind.